Add Ingredients: Combine all your ingredients (except alcohol if using) in a large sauce pot and bring to a gentle boil. You can either stick your whole cloves into your orange halves or just let them float in the pot.
Simmer on Low: Bring your Wassail down to a low simmer and let it gently cook for 30-45 minutes.
Serve: Strain any floating spices and fruit out of your drink and pour into heatproof cups (you can pour it through a fine mesh strainer). Add a shot of alcohol to spike the drink if desired!
Notes
TIP: You can also put all your whole spices into a little sack made from cheesecloth and tie it with bakers twine so you can pull them all out together once you’re ready to serve.